Value Buddy — 16.5x ROI
Value Buddy went from time-intensive manual prospecting to 70 qualified meetings and 12 closed deals in 4 months, while dramatically cutting the time their founding team spent on outreach. The key was segmentation: Fractional CFOs respond to speed and workflow messaging, while traditional advisors respond to client-ready outputs and regulatory defensibility. One message track for both audiences would have failed.Total Spend
$7,200
Revenue Generated
$126,000
ROI
16.5x
Meetings Booked
70
Cost Per Meeting
$103
New MRR Added
$31,500
| Detail | Info |
|---|---|
| Industry | Financial Services / SaaS |
| Company Size | 10-50 employees |
| Services Used | Email + AI Calling + LinkedIn |
| Duration | 4 months |
The Challenge
Value Buddy needed to reach Fractional CFOs and financial advisors — a sophisticated audience that sees through generic outreach instantly and evaluates businesses for a living. Generic SaaS pitches were non-starters with this audience. Messaging had to be sharp, substantiated, and segmented because CFOs and advisors buy for fundamentally different reasons. Manual prospecting was consuming significant founding team time with no differentiation between CFO and advisor segments and no systematic outbound pipeline. Before Outbound System:- Significant time spent on manual prospecting
- No differentiation between CFO and advisor segments
- Generic financial services messaging
- No systematic outbound pipeline
- 70 qualified meetings in 4 months
- 12 deals closed from outbound pipeline
- Dramatic reduction in manual prospecting time
- Segmented approach for CFOs vs. advisors producing 2x difference in response
The Solution
Lists built through multi-source enrichment, cross-referencing advisory firm databases, LinkedIn activity, and professional certifications. Segmentation separated Fractional CFOs (speed and workflow) from traditional advisors (client-ready outputs and regulatory defensibility). Send timing was optimized around financial services patterns — early morning, mid-week.Cold Email
Primary channel with segment-specific messaging. Azure U.S. IP infrastructure for enterprise filter delivery. Fractional CFOs received speed-focused messaging; advisors received defensibility-focused messaging. Each segment’s response rate validated the segmentation thesis.LinkedIn Outreach
Targeted the same prospects with engagement around valuation methodology and financial advisory content, building credibility before the email arrived.AI Cold Calling
Direct touchpoint for high-value advisory firms where a 60-second conversation about valuation workflow quickly qualified interest and moved prospects to meetings.Beyond the Meetings
- Market Intelligence: Multi-source enrichment revealed active practitioners with current certifications converted at 4x the rate of semi-retired consultants, dramatically improving list quality.
- Pipeline Insurance: Three-channel coverage ensured that during tax season when email engagement dropped, calling and LinkedIn kept pipeline flowing.
- ICP Refinement: Fractional CFOs responded to speed-focused messaging at 2x the rate of feature-focused, while advisors showed the opposite, validating the segmentation.
- Time Recovery: Beyond meetings, the campaign cut founding team prospecting time significantly, freeing capacity for product development and client delivery.
Campaign Timeline
Weeks 1-2: Prospect Enrichment
Multi-source prospect enrichment across advisory firm databases, LinkedIn activity, and certifications. CFO vs. advisor segmentation defined. Segment-specific messaging developed.
Weeks 3-4: Campaign Launch
Timing optimized for financial services (early morning, mid-week sends). First meetings booked within 6 days. Response rates immediately diverging by segment as expected.
Month 2: Multi-Channel Expansion
AI calling added for high-value firms. LinkedIn building financial services credibility. Pipeline velocity increasing as segment-specific messaging refined.
Full Metrics Breakdown
| Metric | Result |
|---|---|
| Total Spend with Outbound System | $7,200 |
| Campaign Duration | 4 months |
| Qualified Leads Generated | 82 |
| Cost Per Qualified Lead | $88 |
| Meetings / Calls Booked | 70 |
| Cost Per Booked Meeting | $103 |
| Show Up Rate | 83% |
| Revenue Generated (cash collected) | $126,000 |
| New MRR Added | $31,500 |
| ROAS (on cash collected) | 17.50x |
| Total ROI | 16.5x |
“Outbound System’s onboarding and ongoing support is great. They were truly thought partners while creating our campaign, and the user interface is sleek. We’ve generated around 70 meetings so far and have cut down on our time spent messaging significantly.” — Cameron Long, Co-Founder at Value Buddy
Get Results Like Value Buddy
Value Buddy’s campaign proved that sophisticated buyers require segment-specific messaging to convert — one track for Fractional CFOs, a completely different track for traditional advisors. If you’re a SaaS company or selling into financial services, the segmentation principle applies: identify how different buyer personas evaluate your product, and build a messaging track for each. See how our cold email service handles multi-segment campaigns and our LinkedIn outbound builds credibility with hard-to-reach financial professionals.Book a Strategy Call
See how buyer segmentation and multi-channel outbound would work for your SaaS pipeline.